Former Miss Florida Citrus
Former Florida Citrus Queens
2024 Alana Scheuerer
2023 Casana Fink
2022 Payton Barrington
2020/21 Leila Sabet (COVID-extended reign)
2019 Juliana Fray
2019 Michaela McLean (Miss Florida 2019)
2018 Megan Price
2017 Rachel Smith
2016 Stephanie Capon
2015 Summer Foley
No pageant was held between 2005 and 2014
2004 Nichole "Nikki" Upthegrove
2003 Morgan Ortagus
2001 Jennifer Peavey
2000 Kimber Wood
1999 Kim Duppenthaler
1998 Shannon Potts McDonald
1997 Becka Cerni Robinson
1996 Dana Morgan
1995 Candy Griffin Denton
1994 Tobitha Bryant Yeomans
1993 Emily Howell Rogers
1992 Sheri Cook Richardson
1991 Mandy Hancock Jarrett
1990 Laura Benefield Pulido
1989 Sherry Hensley
1988 Judy Beretto Prisk
1987 Renee McLeod Graham
1986 Rosemarie Payne
1984 Lori Schirard Grubb
1983 Deidra Perkins McLeod
1982 Dawn Griffin
1981 Brenda Eubanks Burnette
1980 Teresa Mahoney Shuster
1979 Nancy Ness
1978 Lisa Lyon
1977 Lisa Maile D'Alessandro
1976 Candace Upthegrove
1975 Sonya Surrency
1974 Debi Adair
1973 Wanda Lynn Miller
1972 Christine Couldron
1971 Sue Comer
1970 Suzanne Rogers
1969 Kathy Young
1968 Lynee Allen
1967 Patti Bohannon
1966 La Voyce Leggett
1965 Karol Kelly
1964 Nancy Collins
1963 Sue Scarborough
1962 Sharon Conrad
1961 Sandra Guthrie
1960 Florence Cloud
1959 Sandra Freeman
1958 Kay MacLean
1957 Frances Layton
1956 Dorothy Steiner
1955 Sally Ardrey
1954 Ann Daniel
(Miss Florida 1954 and 1st Runner Up Miss America)
1953 Marion Ettie
1952 Pat Burgoon
1951 Carolyn Stroupe
1950 Kathy Darlyn
1949 Joan Cook
1948 Shirley Rhodes
1947 Nance Stilley
1946 Selma Rocker
1945 Laurel Norden
1943 Sylvia Chambliss
1942 Iveane Hall
1941 Elizabeth Colson
1940 Leone Johnson
1939 Mary Frances Capp
1938 Beth Page
1937 Doris Harrison
1936 Bee Huyck
1935 Betty Runkle
1934 Marjorie Giddens
1933 Mary Lou Moore
1932 Kathleen Kelly
1931 Bertha Knight
1930 Ruth Snider
1924 Dorothy Williamson
​
​